Asmaller textAnormal textAlarger text

Campaign Finance Board Assesses Penalties Against One Candidate

June 11, 2009

During a regularly scheduled meeting today, the Campaign Finance Board assessed penalties against one candidate. Penalties were assessed against the campaigns of Mathieu Eugene for City Council in special elections of February 20 and April 24, 2007, and the regular fall election of November 2007. For details, see below:

Penalties Assessed

Candidate Office Public Funds Received Violation Penalty Total Penalties
Mathieu Eugene (2007A) CD# 40 $0 Failing to respond to the Draft Audit Report $1,459 $10,472
Accepting three over-the-limit contributions $2,152 and VNP
Accepting two corporate contributions $2,700
Failing to report and document the value of five in-kind contributions $1,250
Failing to document the value of two in-kind contributions $100
Failing to report, or establish the absence of, subcontractors $50
Failing to provide bank statements $250
Disbursements variance of 12.6% $500
Cash receipts variance of 110% $500
Improper post-election expenditures totaling $6,366 $500
Non-campaign related expenditures totaling $20,216 $1,011
Mathieu Eugene (2007B) CD# 40 *NP Failing to respond to the Draft Audit Report $543 $275
Accepting an over-the-limit contribution VNP
Accepting a corporate contribution $2,650
Failing to document the value of an in-kind contribution $50
Making four cash expenditures greater than $100 $487
Filing Disclosure Statement 4 one day late $50
Failing to provide bank statements $50
Monetary receipts variance of 97.7% $2,000
Disbursements variance of 192.6% $3,000
Petty cash fund in excess of $500 $160
Mathieu Eugene (2007) CD# 40 $0 Failing to respond to the Draft Audit Report $522 $5,122
Accepting an over-the-limit contribution VNP
Accepting two corporate contributions $3,700
Failing to document the value of two in-kind contributions $100
Making three cash expenditures greater than $100 $300
Filing Disclosure Statement 6 four days late $200
Improper post-election expenditures totaling $2,625 $250
Failing to provide bank statements $50
TOTAL = $24,584

* Mathieu Eugene was not a participant in the Campaign Finance Program for the 2007B special election.

The Board adopted final rules. The amendments clarify specific Board rules regarding the application of the spending limits for expenditures related to transfers; provide deadlines for attendance at a post-election audit training; and clarify that a petition for review of a post-election public funds determination must be submitted within 30 days of the issuance of the final audit report. The rules can be found here later today.

The Board also issued for public comment proposed amendments to its rules. The proposed amendments would conform the Board’s rules to recent amendments to the New York State Freedom of Information Law and changes to the Campaign Finance Act contained in Local Law Nos. 34 and 67 of 2007. The proposed changes, would, among other things: provide a standard for determining when a document is considered to be issued or provided by the Board, and conform Board rules to the rules of the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings for the formal candidate hearings that take place under the City Administrative Procedure Act. Written public comments will be accepted until July 20, 2009, the anticipated date of the public hearing on the proposed rule changes. The proposed rules can be found here later today.

The next public meeting of the New York City Campaign Finance Board will be held at 10:00 a.m. on Thursday, July 9 at 40 Rector Street in Lower Manhattan (between Washington and West Streets), New York, NY 10006.